Skip to content

0008 Plain download links only where nothing new can become visible

Sources: #510, #539

Context and Problem Statement

A plain download link works for whoever holds it. The server checks no sign-in for it. So the server gives plain links only for an open source, one where every caller sees the same.

A common policy is "show everything except the personal column": "default": "show" with one field at hide. Such a source got no plain links (#510). Which sources should count as open?

Considered Options

  • Count hide as open. "Show everything except" gets plain links. #510 proposed this.
  • State the old rule in the docs and keep it.
  • Open only where nothing new can become visible, for every caller alike. #539 built this.

Decision Outcome

Chosen option: open only where nothing new can become visible.

Open:

  • every field show, nothing hidden
  • hidden by default ("default": "hide") with every named field at show or hide

Closed:

  • "show everything except X" ("default": "show" with a field at hide)
  • any field or default at values or summary, and the automatic values rule
  • a field shown to some callers only

The reason recorded in #539: under "show everything except", a column the data gains later would be shown behind a plain link.

Consequences

  • Good: a link stays safe when the data gains a column.
  • Bad: "show everything except" needs a change for plain links. Set the default to hide and list the fields to show.
  • check-config says what closes each source.